Karma XPU vs Redshift - A Comprehensive Review
CG Forge CG Forge
20.6K subscribers
15,458 views
675

 Published On Premiered Mar 25, 2024

If you're interested in downloading the scene files for yourself, then visit this link:
https://www.cgforge.com/karma-rs-revi...

Timestamps:

00:00:00 - Intro
00:01:47 - Testing Criteria

Criteria 1: Speed

00:02:47 - How Scenes Were Tested
00:10:50 - Shaderbot Lineup
00:11:28 - Adaptive Tessellation
00:11:38 - Bubble Blob
00:12:25 - Caustics
00:12:35 - Global Illumination
00:13:31 - Volume Rendering
00:14:10 - Motion Blur
00:14:20 - Instancing
00:14:31 - Stability
00:15:01 - Shaderbot Commentary
00:17:10 - Tessellation Commentary
00:18:19 - Bubble Blob Commentary
00:21:29 - Caustics Commentary
00:22:43 - Global Illumination Commentary
00:25:03 - Volume Rendering Commentary
00:26:22 - Motion Blur
00:27:08 - Instancing Test

Criteria 2: Features

00:29:04 - Considerations for Features
00:29:44 - Features List
00:30:29 - Features Commentary

Criteria 3: User Experience

00:31:15 - Redshift Documentation
00:33:55 - Karma Documentation
00:37:19 - Redshift Color Correction
00:39:11 - Karma Color Correction
00:42:06 - Redshift Viewport Integration
00:42:37 - Karma Solaris Viewport Overrides
00:46:08 - Renderview Comparisons
00:47:40 - PostFX
00:48:42 - Karma Viewport Render Settings
00:49:54 - Render Settings Comparison
00:51:49 - Commentary About USD

Criteria 4: Pricing

00:54:51 - Houdini Pricing
00:56:00 - Redshift Pricing
00:56:21 - Pricing Breakdown Scenario

Criteria 5: Visual Quality

01:00:35 - Defining Visual Quality
01:01:17 - Final Thoughts

** Karma partially supports matte objects
---------
For more high quality content, visit https://www.cgforge.com
Thanks for watching!

show more

Share/Embed