Carly turns around to see Todd walking in. She dumbfounded, not know the charges against Todd were dropped. Todd tells her what happen and wants her back. Carly refuses over and over. Todd continues to tells her everything she wants to hear. Finally Carly runs out of excuses and lies to Todd by saying she's with A.J. Who just walks in. A.J comes over and asks "What's going on?" Carly explains (in another lie) and kisses A.J in front of Todd. Todd watches in disgust.